Posted by: parallelsidewalk | June 21, 2008

Russert In Hell

The lovely folks at Westboro Baptist have decided that Tim Russert is in hell for supporting the “fag agenda” with his journalism. I believe Fred Phelps actually invokes the phrase “bully pulpit” at some point, a term that seemed quaint back when Teddy Roosevelt threw it around. I don’t remember Russert ever being particularly pro-gay, and the WBC congregation are of course completely fucking insane, but I’m not sure I completely disagree with them. If there’s a good old fashioned fire and brimstone hell, I have to assume that Russert is there right now, forced to act as Raymond Burr’s understudy for all eternity and/or being jabbed with picthforks. My assumption isn’t based on any deep love I suspect that a conservative Irish Catholic like Russert had for gays, but rather for his role in helping sell this stupid, endless war to the American public. As an accomplice to almost a million deaths and counting, Russert is imaginable nowhere else but the depths of the 8th circle.

Of course, the scorn heaped on the WBC members by the American Public is sadly predictable. It’s not that they don’t deserve it, you understand, it’s that they’re such a ridiculously easy target and it’s so easy to go after them even as house resolutions are passed (unanimously) to honor a whore like Tim. Fred Phelps is an asshole, I mean, you have to consider that he was disbarred for repeated breaches of ethics; it takes a lot of work to be considered an albatross around the neck of the legal community. But realistically, the WBC is basically that guy and his family and have zero power or credibility even with the most far right protestant nutcases. The closest thing to a genuine fascist in mainstream American discourse, Sean Hannity, thinks they’re extremist crazies. McCain courted Hagee but he stays the hell away from these guys. They’re pretty much only infamous due to their love of extreme hyperbole and talent for self-promotion, not unlike Eminem. There are a lot of people in this country who have done a lot more harm, and just use more genteel language, and Tim Russert was completely willing to be buddy buddy with those people and even help them do their damage.

So I can’t really claim I’m too offended by the morons this time; I’m offended by the unwillingness of Americans to actually talk truth to people in power, or to recognize the crimes of the dead, turning every public figure who’s reached room temperature into some sort of hero. Rot in hell Tim Russert, and I can only hope that you and Phelps are sharing an apartment across the hall from Andy Dick and R Kelly in a few years.

Responses

gotta disagree with you on this one Dave, on the “russert rot in hell” sentiment. i dont think any good comes from speaking ill of the dead. their matter in this world is finished and what happens to them now is up to God (this is the Muslim in me speaking).

i was no fan of benazir bhutto when she was alive, and was annoyed with the saintly image of her the media was painting after her death, but i would never go so far as to wish she rots in hell. russert (and her) were still someone’s parent and child, and as much as we disagree with their decisions while alive, cursing them while they’re dead is just not necessary.

no offense intended to you, ofcourse.

I see where you’re coming from, and it wasn’t too long ago that I would have agreed. Even when Bhutto died, I sort of held my tongue and tried to ignore the way she was transformed into this angelic last hope for democracy. Maybe I’m a little influenced by my anger over the constant praise of Russert I see everywhere since he kicked off, but my internal logic has also changed somewhat. It’s true that Tim was someone’s child and someone’s father, but this is also true of the hundreds of thousands dead in part because he acted as a stooge for the Bush administration. I don’t normally attack people when they’re dead, and I still wouldn’t do it over trivialities; I never cared much for Russert’s style or presentation, but I don’t see any need to get into that because it would just be sort of crass. It’s probably not necessary, agreed, but I just feel like we can’t let him off the hook because his heart stopped, and all the “He was the best!” talk bugs me because he most definitely was not the best, but a partisan hack who acted in the interests of his masters at all times, whether it was disseminating the white house bottom line unquestioningly, very possibly helping to out Valerie Plame, or readily going after anybody who appeared on his show and helping the right wing propaganda machine use slander and invective. The best time to kill revisionism is at the source, so maybe I’m being a bit harsh, but Tim Russert was not even a good journalist and ultimately I don’t want to forget that.

Yeah I don’t follow the cnn too closely besides Lou Dobbs purely for entertainment value; all I remembered of this guy at the time of his death was the questioning Obama about the Farrakan endorsement at the debates, so I was a little weirded out when I saw all these liberals mourning him on forums as such a great guy that “we needed.” Now reading that other stuff which I kind of suspected anyways since it was the norm for journalists at the time, I don’t feel great being vindicated but I’m not suprised. Goddamn gross, we have set the bar so fucking low it’s really not funny.

Hey I just got back give me a couple of days to catch up with the internet.

Right, Russert was well known for lobbing softball questions to his rightward guests and then letting them run with them without much cross-examination, and then asking demos “tough” questions even in circumstances that seemed somewhat bizarre. The idea that seems to have surfaced that he was a rigorous and scrupulous independent journalist is just weird. CJR and Huffington Post both had features called “Russert Watch” which were pretty critical of this bias at the time. Liberals are gutless though, as they showed when they started praising ruthless archfoes Reagan and Goldwater after they died. I’m not asking for angry denunciation, but it’s hypocritical to act crushed when someone you spent years fighting the idea of dies. At any rate, Russert as very, very clearly a creature of the Bush administration and didn’t even try to hide his personal love for it, or his willingness to give Dick Cheney an open forum.

Yeah I figured there might be some hyperbole going on here.

What did Andy Dick do though, or is it just for being annoying.

Just for being annoying.

Leave a response

Your response:

Categories